Difference between revisions of "Permeable paving"

From LID SWM Planning and Design Guide
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(28 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[File:PP IWS.gif|thumb|Conceptual diagram illustrating an adjustable storage underdrain configuration beneath permeable interlocking pavers]]
+
[[File:PP IWS.gif|frame|Conceptual diagram illustrating an adjustable storage underdrain configuration beneath permeable interlocking pavers]]
 
{{TOClimit|2}}
 
{{TOClimit|2}}
 
==Overview==
 
==Overview==
Line 30: Line 30:
  
 
===Geometry and Site Layout===
 
===Geometry and Site Layout===
Permeable paving can be used for entire parking lot areas or driveways and can be designed to receive runoff from adjacent impervious surfaces. For example, the parking spaces in a parking lot may be permeable pavers while the drive lanes themselves are impervious asphalt. In general, the impervious area should not exceed 1.2 times the area of the permeable paving which receives the runoff. A hybrid permeable paving/[[infiltration chambers|infiltration chamber]] design can feature connection of a roof downspout directly to the stone reservoir of the permeable paving system, which is sized to store runoff from both the pavement surface and the roof drainage area.  
+
[[File:Perforated concrete block alt.jpg|thumb|Parking lot with perforated pavers in stalls only, Singapore]]
 +
Permeable paving can be used for entire parking lot areas or driveways and can be designed to receive runoff from adjacent impervious surfaces. For example, the parking spaces in a parking lot may be permeable pavers while the drive lanes themselves are impervious asphalt. In general, the impervious area should not exceed the area of the permeable paving which receives the runoff.  
 +
A hybrid permeable paving/[[infiltration chambers|infiltration chamber]] design can feature connection of a roof [[downspout]] directly to the stone reservoir of the permeable paving system, which is sized to store runoff from both the pavement surface and the roof drainage area.
  
 
===Pretreatment===
 
===Pretreatment===
Line 39: Line 41:
  
 
===Risk of Groundwater Contamination===
 
===Risk of Groundwater Contamination===
*Stormwater infiltration practices should not receive runoff from high traffic areas where large amounts of de-icing salts are applied (e.g., busy highways), nor from pollution hot spots (e.g., source areas where land uses or activities have the potential to generate highly contaminated runoff such as vehicle fuelling, servicing or demolition areas, outdoor storage or handling areas for hazardous materials and some heavy industry sites)
+
*Stormwater infiltration practices should not receive runoff from high traffic areas where large amounts of [[de-icing salts]] are applied (e.g., busy highways), nor from pollution hot spots (e.g., source areas where land uses or activities have the potential to generate highly contaminated runoff such as vehicle fuelling, servicing or demolition areas, outdoor storage or handling areas for hazardous materials and some heavy industry sites)
*Prioritize infiltration of runoff from source areas that are comparatively less contaminated such as   roofs, low traffic roads and parking areas
+
*Prioritize infiltration of runoff from source areas that are comparatively less contaminated such as roofs and low traffic areas.
*Apply sedimentation pretreatment practices (e.g., oil and grit separators) before infiltration of road or parking area runoff
 
  
 
===Heavy Vehicle Traffic===
 
===Heavy Vehicle Traffic===
 +
[[File:PaveDrain.jpg|thumb|Many types of permeable surface are certified to ASSHTO-25, including PaveDrain PICP type paving, LSRCA headquarters, Newmarket, ON]]
 
Permeable paving is not typically used in locations subject to heavy loads. However, some permeable pavers are designed for heavy loads and have been used in commercial port loading and storage areas.
 
Permeable paving is not typically used in locations subject to heavy loads. However, some permeable pavers are designed for heavy loads and have been used in commercial port loading and storage areas.
  
Line 54: Line 56:
 
==Design==
 
==Design==
 
===Finish course===
 
===Finish course===
 +
Consult the manufacturer for the design specifications of their product. In pervious concrete and porous asphalt systems, the concrete or asphalt mix specifications and construction procedures are key to proper functioning. These systems require well-trained and experienced contractors for installation.
  
 +
{{:Permeable paving: Specifications}}
 +
 +
===Foundation aggregates===
 +
[[File:Geogitter-4.jpg|thumb|Geogrids like these are sometimes incorporated into the layers of permeable pavement foundation aggregates to provide additional stability]]
 +
Most [[OPSS aggregates]] are not recommended for use in permeable paving systems. The exception being type 'o' with a default void ratio of 0.3.
 +
*[[Choker layer]]
 +
*[[Reservoir aggregate]]
 +
 +
===Geotextile===
 +
[[Geotextiles]] are not always necessary and may be prone to [[clogging]]. Consider using courses of finer aggregates or sand instead.
  
 
===Sizing stone reservoirs===
 
===Sizing stone reservoirs===
Line 68: Line 81:
 
==Gallery==
 
==Gallery==
 
{{:Permeable paving: Gallery}}
 
{{:Permeable paving: Gallery}}
===Materials===
 
Consult the manufacturer for the design specifications of their product. In pervious concrete and porous asphalt systems, the concrete or asphalt mix specifications and construction procedures are key to proper functioning. These systems require well-trained and experienced contractors for installation.<br>
 
'''[[Permeable paving: Specifications|Specifications]]'''
 
===Aggregates===
 
{{:choker layer}}
 
{{:Reservoir aggregate}}
 
===Geotextile===
 
{{:Geotextiles}}
 
  
===Landscaping===
+
==Landscaping and grading==
Landscaped areas should drain away from permeable paving to prevent sediments from running onto the surface. Urban [[trees]] benefit from being surrounded by permeable pavement rather than impervious cover, because their roots receive more air and water, and pavers used around the base of a tree can be removed as the tree grows.
+
Landscaped areas ''must'' be [[grading|graded]] drain away from permeable paving to prevent sediment from running onto the surface. <br>
 +
Urban [[trees]] benefit from being surrounded by permeable pavement rather than impervious cover, because their roots receive more air and water. Block pavers around the base of a tree can be removed as the tree grows.
  
 
==Performance==
 
==Performance==
Line 104: Line 110:
 
==Proprietary Links==
 
==Proprietary Links==
 
{{:Disclaimer}}
 
{{:Disclaimer}}
===Pre-cast===
+
===Pre-cast with joints===
 
*[https://unilock.com/products/driveways/eco-optiloc/?region=1 Eco-Optioc, Unilock]
 
*[https://unilock.com/products/driveways/eco-optiloc/?region=1 Eco-Optioc, Unilock]
 
*[https://oakspavers.com/products/enviro-pavers Enviro Pavers, Oaks]
 
*[https://oakspavers.com/products/enviro-pavers Enviro Pavers, Oaks]
*[http://hydropavers.ca/ Hydropavers pervious pavers]
 
 
*[http://nilex.com/products/pavedrain Pavedrain, distributed by Nilex]
 
*[http://nilex.com/products/pavedrain Pavedrain, distributed by Nilex]
 
*[http://santerrastonecraft.com/landscape/paving-stones/terra-flo Terra flo, Santerra]
 
*[http://santerrastonecraft.com/landscape/paving-stones/terra-flo Terra flo, Santerra]
 +
 +
===Pre-cast pervious===
 +
*[http://hydropavers.ca/ Hydropavers pervious pavers]
 
*[http://www.storm-crete.com/ Stormcrete pervious pavers]
 
*[http://www.storm-crete.com/ Stormcrete pervious pavers]
===Poured in place===
+
 
 +
===Cast in place===
 
*[http://www.lafarge-na.com/wps/portal/na/en/HydromediaDetailWCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connectlib_na/Site_na/AllProductDataSheet_Concrete/ProductDatasheet_Concrete_1321037540751/Product_EN Hydromedia]
 
*[http://www.lafarge-na.com/wps/portal/na/en/HydromediaDetailWCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connectlib_na/Site_na/AllProductDataSheet_Concrete/ProductDatasheet_Concrete_1321037540751/Product_EN Hydromedia]
 +
*[https://www.purepave.com/ PurePave]
 +
 +
===Plastic grid===
 +
*[https://www.ecorastergrid.com/ Ecoraster]
 +
*[https://www.hahnplastics.com/ca/products/ground-reinforcement-and-surfaces/hanpave/4468/hanpave Hanpave]
 +
*[https://www.hahnplastics.com/ca/products/ground-reinforcement-and-surfaces/heavy-duty-ground-grid/4533/heavy-duty-ground-grid HAHN heavy duty ground grid]
 
----
 
----

Revision as of 19:37, 14 January 2019

Conceptual diagram illustrating an adjustable storage underdrain configuration beneath permeable interlocking pavers

Overview[edit]

Permeable paving allows stormwater to drain through the surface and into a stone reservoir, where it infiltrates into the underlying native soil or is temporarily detained.

The following are different types of permeable paving:

  • Permeable interlocking concrete pavers (PICP)
  • Plastic or concrete grid systems
  • Pervious concrete
  • Pervious asphalt

Permeable paving is ideal for:

  • Sites with limited space for other surface stormwater BMPs
  • Projects such as low traffic roads, parking lots, driveways, pedestrian plazas and walkways

The fundamental components of a permeable paving system are:

  • interlocking blocks with infiltration spaces between
  • Precast pervious slabs or pavers
  • a cast in place surface without fines, so that the finish is pervious to water
  • a bedding course to stabilize the surface
  • underground storage layer of aggregate

Additional components may include:

Planning considerations[edit]

Permeable pavements are surfaces that encourage infiltration. They can be used in place of conventional asphalt or concrete pavement. These alternatives contain pores, spaces and joints for allowing stormwater to pass through to a stone base, where it infiltrates into underlying native soils or is temporarily detained. Types of permeable pavement include:

  • Pervious concrete
  • Porous asphalt
  • Permeable interlocking concrete pavers (PICP, or just permeable pavers)

Geometry and Site Layout[edit]

Parking lot with perforated pavers in stalls only, Singapore

Permeable paving can be used for entire parking lot areas or driveways and can be designed to receive runoff from adjacent impervious surfaces. For example, the parking spaces in a parking lot may be permeable pavers while the drive lanes themselves are impervious asphalt. In general, the impervious area should not exceed the area of the permeable paving which receives the runoff. A hybrid permeable paving/infiltration chamber design can feature connection of a roof downspout directly to the stone reservoir of the permeable paving system, which is sized to store runoff from both the pavement surface and the roof drainage area.

Pretreatment[edit]

In most designs, the surface acts as pretreatment to the stone reservoir below. Periodic vacuum sweeping and preventative measures like not storing snow or other materials on the pavement are critical to prevent clogging. Another pretreatment element is to have a choking layer above the coarse gravel storage reservoir.

Landscaping[edit]

Landscaped areas must drain away from permeable paving to prevent sediments from running onto the surface. Urban trees will benefit from being surrounded by permeable paving rather than impervious cover, because their roots receive more air and water. Interlocking pavers used around the base of a tree may be removed as the tree grows.

Risk of Groundwater Contamination[edit]

  • Stormwater infiltration practices should not receive runoff from high traffic areas where large amounts of de-icing salts are applied (e.g., busy highways), nor from pollution hot spots (e.g., source areas where land uses or activities have the potential to generate highly contaminated runoff such as vehicle fuelling, servicing or demolition areas, outdoor storage or handling areas for hazardous materials and some heavy industry sites)
  • Prioritize infiltration of runoff from source areas that are comparatively less contaminated such as roofs and low traffic areas.

Heavy Vehicle Traffic[edit]

Many types of permeable surface are certified to ASSHTO-25, including PaveDrain PICP type paving, LSRCA headquarters, Newmarket, ON

Permeable paving is not typically used in locations subject to heavy loads. However, some permeable pavers are designed for heavy loads and have been used in commercial port loading and storage areas.

Setbacks from Buildings[edit]

Permeable paving should be located downslope from building foundations. If the paving does not receive runoff from other surfaces, no setback is required from building foundations. Otherwise, a minimum setback of 4 m down-gradient from building foundations is recommended.

On Private Property[edit]

If permeable paving systems are installed on private lots, property owners or managers will need education on their routine maintenance needs, understanding the long-term maintenance plan. They may also be subject to a legally binding maintenance agreement. An incentive program, such as a storm sewer user fee based on the area of impervious cover on a property that is directly connected to a storm sewer, could be used to encourage property owners or managers to maintain existing practices.

Design[edit]

Finish course[edit]

Consult the manufacturer for the design specifications of their product. In pervious concrete and porous asphalt systems, the concrete or asphalt mix specifications and construction procedures are key to proper functioning. These systems require well-trained and experienced contractors for installation.

Specifications for pervious concrete, porous asphalt, and permeable pavers
Material Specification Quantity
Pervious concrete
  • NO4-RG-S7 mix with air entrainment proven to have the best freeze-thaw durability after 300 freeze-thaw cycles.
  • 28 day compressive strength = 5.5 to 20 MPa.
  • Porosity between 14% to 31%.
  • Permeability = 900 to 21,500 mm/hr.
  • Proprietary pre-cast slabs meeting required specifications are also available.
Thickness will range from 100 mm - 150 mm depending on the expected loads.
Porous asphalt
  • Open-graded asphalt mix with a minimum porosity of 16%.
  • Polymers can be added to provide additional strength to heavy loads.
  • The University of New Hampshire Stormwater Center has detailed design specifications for porous asphalt.
Thickness will range from 50 mm - 100 mm depending on the expected loads.
Permeable Interlocking Pavements
  • Pavers shall meet the minimum material and standard specifications for precast concrete pavers (CSA A231.2 in Canada; ASTM C936 in United States).
  • Open space between pavers (i.e. joint space) typically ranges between 5 and 15% of the total surface area.
  • ASTM No. 8 (5 mm dia.) crushed aggregate is recommended for fill material in the paver joints (typically HPB).
  • For narrow joint pavers, a smaller sized aggregate may be used. Narrow joints are required where pavement must be AODA compliant.
  • For vehicle applications the minimum paver thickness is 80 mm
  • For pedestrian applications the minimum paver thickness is 60 mm and joint widths should be no greater than 15 mm.
Stone Resevoir
  • All aggregates should meet the following criteria: (i) maximum wash loss of 0.5%, (ii) minimum durability index of 35, (iii) maximum abrasion of 10% for

100 revolutions and maximum of 50% for 500 revolutions

  • Most OPSS aggregates are not recommended for PP, with the exception of ‘granular O’.
  • The granular subbase material shall consist of granular material graded in accordance with ASTM D 2940. Material should be clear crushed 50 mm diameter stone with void space ratio of 0.4.
  • The granular base material shall be crushed stone conforming to ASTM C 33 No 57. Material should be clear crushed 20 mm diameter stone.
  • The granular bedding material shall be graded in accordance with ASTM C 33 No 8. Typical bedding thickness is 40 to 75 mm. Material should be 5 mm diameter stone or as determined by the Design Engineer. In Ontario, high performance bedding (1 to 9 mm diameter) or equivalent is often used.
  • See LID Planning and Design Wiki (Permeable pavements: Sizing) to size aggregate bed depth and multiply by application area to get total volume.
Geotextile
  • Should be woven monofilament or non-woven needle punched fabrics. Woven slit film and non-woven heat bonded fabrics should not be used as they are prone to clogging.
  • Primary considerations for Geotextile are:
    • suitable apparent opening size (AOS) for non-woven fabrics, or percent open area (POA) for woven fabrics, to maintain water flow even with sediment and microbial film build-up
    • maximum forces to be exerted on the fabric (i.e tensile, tear and puncture strengths required)
    • load bearing ratio of the underlying native soil (i.e. is geotextile needed to prevent downward migration of aggregate into the native soil?),
    • grain size distribution of the overlying aggregate material, and
    • permeability of the native soil.
  • Geotextiles are not always necessary and may be prone to eventual clogging. Consider using sand or fine aggregates instead. Where they are necessary (typically on low strength soils of CBR <4) between stone reservoir and native soil, material specifications should conform to Ontario Provincial Standard Specification (OPSS) 1860 for Class II geotextile fabrics. Geotextile socks on pipes should conform to ASTM D6707 with a min. water flow rate conforming to ASTM D4491 (12,263 L/min/m2 at 5 cm head).
Underdrain (optional)
  • PVC or HDPE, continuously perforated with smooth interior and a minimum inside diameter of 200 mm.
  • Perforations in pipes should be 10 mm in diameter.
  • A standpipe from the underdrain to the pavement surface can be used for monitoring and maintenance of the underdrain. The top of the standpipe should be covered with a screw cap and a vandal-proof lock.

Pipes should terminate 0.3 m short from the sides of the base.

Foundation aggregates[edit]

Geogrids like these are sometimes incorporated into the layers of permeable pavement foundation aggregates to provide additional stability

Most OPSS aggregates are not recommended for use in permeable paving systems. The exception being type 'o' with a default void ratio of 0.3.

Geotextile[edit]

Geotextiles are not always necessary and may be prone to clogging. Consider using courses of finer aggregates or sand instead.

Sizing stone reservoirs[edit]

The stone reservoir must meet both runoff storage and structural support requirements. The bottom of the reservoir should be level so that water infiltrates evenly.
If the system is not designed for infiltration, the bottom should slope at 1 - 5% toward the underdrain.

Permeable paving: Sizing

Modeling permeable paving in the Treatment Train Tool[edit]

Permeable paving: TTT

Gallery[edit]

Landscaping and grading[edit]

Landscaped areas must be graded drain away from permeable paving to prevent sediment from running onto the surface.
Urban trees benefit from being surrounded by permeable pavement rather than impervious cover, because their roots receive more air and water. Block pavers around the base of a tree can be removed as the tree grows.

Performance[edit]

Starting after TRIECA (end March) members of STEP will be undertaking a literature review on the performance of our most popular BMPs. The results will be combined with the information we have to date from the development of the Treatment Train Tool and agreed performance metrics established. Until then, please feel free to continue to ask questions via email or the feedback box below.

Permeable pavers can be classified into two categories according to the infiltration rate of the underlying subsoil:

  • Full Infiltration: Full infiltration designs are more effective, because little if any of the pollutants generated on the impermeable surfaces leave the site as surface runoff
  • Partial Infiltration: Partial infiltration designs with underdrains generate more runoff

Studies in North Carolina have shown the average curve number of permeable pavements to range from a low of 45 to a high of 89. [1]
Partial infiltration designs with underdrains generate more runoff, and as a result, are often used in studies investigating the water quality impact of permeable pavements on surface waters. These studies show load reductions above 50% for total suspended solids, most metals and hydrocarbons [2] [3]
As with all stormwater infiltration practices, risk of groundwater contamination from infiltration of runoff laden with road de-icing salt constituents (typically sodium and chloride) is a significant concern. Chloride ions are extremely mobile in the soil and are readily transported by percolating water to aquifers.

Construction Considerations[edit]

Construction of permeable pavement is a specialized project and should involve experienced contractors. The following general recommendations apply:

  • Sediment Control: The treatment area should be fully protected during construction so that no sediment reaches the permeable pavement system and proper erosion and sediment controls must be maintained on site.
  • Weather: Porous asphalt and pervious concrete will not properly pour and set in extremely high or low temperatures [4]. One benefit to using permeable pavers is that their installation is not weather dependent.
  • Pavement placement: Properly installed permeable pavement requires trained and experienced producers and construction contractors.

Inspection and Maintenance[edit]

Permeable pavements require regular inspection and maintenance to ensure proper functioning. The limiting factor for permeable pavers is clogging within the aggregate layers, filler, or underdrain. Ideally, signs should be posted on the site identifying permeable paver and porous pavement areas. This can also serve as a public awareness and education opportunity. See: Permeable paving: Maintenance

Life cycle costs[edit]

Initial construction costs for permeable pavements are typically higher than conventional asphalt pavement surfaces, largely due to thicker aggregate base needed for stormwater storage. However, the cost difference is reduced or eliminated when total life-cycle costs, or the total cost to construct and maintain the pavement over its lifespan, are considered. Other potential savings and benefits include reduced need for storm sewer pipes and other stormwater practices, less developable land consumed for stormwater treatment, and ancillary benefits (improved aesthetics and reduced urban heat island effect). These systems are especially cost effective in existing urban development where parking lot expansion is needed, but there is not sufficient space for other types of BMPs. They combine parking, stormwater infiltration, retention, and detention into one facility. See also: Cost analysis resources

Proprietary Links[edit]

In our effort to make this guide as functional as possible, we have decided to include proprietary systems and links to manufacturers websites.
Inclusion of such links does not constitute endorsement by the Sustainable Technologies Evaluation Program.
Lists are ordered alphabetically; link updates are welcomed using the form below.

Pre-cast with joints[edit]

Pre-cast pervious[edit]

Cast in place[edit]

Plastic grid[edit]


  1. Bean, E.Z., Hunt, W, F., Bidelspach, D.A. 2007a. Evaluation of Four Permeable Pavement Sites in Eastern North Carolina for Runoff Reduction and Water Quality Impacts. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering. Vol. 133. No. 6. pp. 583-592.
  2. Legret, M and V. Colandani. 1999. Effects of a porous pavement structure with a reservoir structure on runoff water: water quality and fate of metals. Water Science and Technology. 39(2): 111-117
  3. Pratt, C.J., Mantle, J.D.G., Schofield, P.A. 1995. UK research into the performance of permeable pavement reservoir structures in controlling stormwater discharge quantity and quality. Water Science Technology. Vol. 32. No. 1. pp. 63-69.
  4. City of Portland. 2004. Portland Stormwater Management Manual. Prepared by the Bureau of Environmental Services (BES). Portland, OR.