Line 375:
Line 375:
==Places of worship==
==Places of worship==
[[File:Landforms of a place of worship.JPG|thumb|Source areas within a typical place of worship]]
[[File:Landforms of a place of worship.JPG|thumb|Source areas within a typical place of worship]]
+
+
Each distinct area of your site can be a source for runoff
+
(referred to as a ‘source area’). One or more of these areas
+
should be targeted when introducing LID at your place of
+
worship.
+
===Targeting hard surfaces===
+
Hard surfaces such as parking lots are a great opportunity to
+
implement LID. Parking lots are the main source of runoff and
+
represent the most significant source of stormwater pollutants
+
coming from your site.
+
Parking lots at places of worship are typically busy only on
+
select days of the week when groups gather for prayer or
+
other community activities. Due to this intermittent schedule,
+
parking lots at these facilities are often rented for other
+
purposes during times of low usage. On sites where peak
+
demand does not approach the total capacity of the lot,
+
consider reducing the parking surface.
+
Retrofit options for these large parking lot areas include
+
permeable pavement, bioswales and bioretention areas.
+
A benefit of permeable pavement systems is that they often
+
have a longer lifespan than conventional infrastructure.
+
The freeze-thaw cycle of the Ontario climate is tough on
+
pavement. Frost heaving and slumping can cause cracks and
+
potholes because of the expansion and contraction of water.
+
The expected lifespan for conventional asphalt pavement
+
in a northern climate, such as Ontario, is approximately 15 to
+
20 years. A well-maintained porous asphalt system can last for
+
over 30 years, and permeable interlocking concrete pavers
+
can have a design life of 20 to 25 years or greater.
+
Using LID techniques to manage stormwater can also
+
eliminate or reduce the need for an on-site storm sewer
+
system. By eliminating piping, failure points in the pavement,
+
such as areas around catch basins and manholes, can be
+
eliminated. A design that does not use storm sewers also
+
negates the need to replace on-site piping, thereby saving
+
long-term infrastructure replacement costs.
+
Prefabricated modular infiltration chambers are gaining
+
acceptance because they are easy to integrate with parking
+
lot functions. These subsurface systems are typically installed
+
over a coarse granular reservoir to provide water storage and
+
allow infiltration into native soils. Infiltration chambers under
+
conventional asphalt systems work well on sites where parking
+
demand does not allow space for a stormwater feature.
+
+
===Landscaped areas===
+
+
Landscaped or lawn areas adjacent to the parking lot or
+
building present opportunities for implementation of LID
+
practices such as bioswales and bioretention areas. These
+
areas typically accept runoff from nearby hard surfaces and
+
provide water quality and water balance benefits.
+
+
===Roof options===
+
+
Rainwater harvesting systems can be simple or complex
+
depending on the architecture and roof drainage patterns of
+
your building. Many places of worship have peaked roofs with
+
piping to convey water from the rooftop. If your site is set up
+
this way, it can be easy to integrate harvesting systems into
+
the landscape surrounding your building.
+
Roof runoff can also be directed to soakaways located on
+
passive use areas around your building. Due to the relatively
+
good quality of this runoff, pre-treatment devices are not
+
required.
+
+
===Source Areas===
+
The LID option that best fits your site will depend what types
+
of source areas are present. Types of source areas include:
+
* Active use area
+
* Passive use area
+
* Pedestrian walkway
+
* Internal driveway
+
* Parking lot
+
+
On park sites, pollution prevention is often associated with
+
changes to operations and maintenance practices and has
+
not been included in Table 6.3.1. An aerial photo of a park
+
with each of these source areas accompanies Table 6.3.1.
+
Options and implementation strategies for a few of these
+
source areas will give you some ideas for your park site.
+
+
The scale
+
of your LID retrofit project will largely determine how you will
+
proceed. You can usually complete
+
small-scale LID projects with in-house expertise and
+
resources. Large-scale projects will require external support
+
from consultants and contractors.
+
+
===Small-scale projects===
+
+
Starting with small-scale projects is a good strategy to
+
increase interest within your community, determine if
+
support is available from stakeholder groups and gain retrofit
+
experience. Small-scale projects include retrofitting your
+
property with landscape alternatives, rain barrels or using
+
pollution prevention strategies and practices.
+
+
Small-scale projects require few resources and a
+
small project budget because:
+
* They do not require integration into capital works projects
+
* Engineering consultants are not required
+
* Contractors are not required
+
* External approvals are not required
+
* Consultation with the public is limited
+
Due to the less significant financial commitment, it can be
+
easier to build the case for support for small-scale projects.
+
A successful small-scale LID retrofit project on your property
+
is a good indication that you are ready to take on a more
+
intensive retrofit project. You now know the resources that Large-scale projects
+
Large-scale projects require significantly more effort, budget,
+
and staff than small-scale projects. Large-scale LID retrofits
+
include:
+
* Bioretention
+
* Enhanced grass swales
+
* Bioswales
+
* Perforated pipe systems
+
* Permeable pavement
+
* Soakaways
+
* Infiltration chambers
+
* Rainwater harvesting (excluding rain barrels)
+
* Prefabricated modules
+
* Green roofs
+
+
Consider a large-scale project if your place of worship is
+
striving to be a community leader in sustainability. Large-scale
+
projects are often highly visible and attract more public
+
attention. They may also be the only solution
+
to site-specific challenges, like poor drainage. Before starting
+
a large-scale retrofit project consider the distinctions that set
+
these retrofits apart from small-scale projects.
+
+
===Integration with long-term infrastructure replacement and rehabilitation plans===
+
+
Most large-scale LID retrofits must function with existing
+
site infrastructure, such as storm sewers, catch basins,
+
and pavement systems. The construction of large-scale
+
LID practices often requires these systems to be removed,
+
exposed, or replaced. The best time for this type of project is when an infrastructure replacement or rehabilitation
+
project is already planned.
+
Maintenance programs and budgets that take into consideration
+
the expected life cycle of critical site components, including
+
parking lot and roofs, are valuable resources for large-scale
+
projects. If the replacement of these features is forecasted in
+
your site budget well in advance, asses if it is advantageous
+
to incorporate LID retrofits into these projects. Remember,
+
sharing construction materials, construction equipment, staff
+
resources, and time will reduce the budget for your retrofit.
+
For example, installing bioretention, infiltration chambers,
+
or permeable pavement in a parking lot will require the
+
existing pavement to be removed. Budget and resources that
+
have been set aside for a parking lot replacement could be
+
transferred to the LID retrofit project.
+
+
===Involvement of consultants and contractors===
+
+
Consultants are required for large-scale retrofit projects,
+
specifically for the final screening of options, pre-design,
+
detailed design, tender and contract documents, construction
+
supervision and administration, and assumption and
+
verification.
+
+
Site contractors are also required for large-scale LID retrofits.
+
Contractors should be pre-qualified based on previous
+
experience with similar LID projects.
+
+
External approvals
+
Large-scale retrofits may require a variety of approvals at the
+
municipal, watershed, provincial, and/or federal level.
+
Since LID is still relatively new, you may encounter policies
+
or bylaws that present barriers to LID retrofit projects.
+
Alternatively, the municipality may have to amend or enforce
+
some policies and bylaws to facilitate the implementation of
+
LID projects on your site.
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
Line 403:
Line 576:
|style="text-align: left;" |Building || * || * || * || ** || ** || * || ** || o || o || *
|style="text-align: left;" |Building || * || * || * || ** || ** || * || ** || o || o || *
|}
|}
+
+
===stuff to maybe integrate into the above===
+
+
'''Figure 6.3.1: When considering any parking lot retrofit, first determine if the parking spaces provided are consistent with the'''
+
demand. In place of worship, the demand will fluctuate. (Source: CVC)
+
+
'''Did you know that green roofs can help'''
+
reduce your heating and cooling costs?
+
These systems absorb heat and act as
+
insulators for buildings. It has been estimated
+
that a 3,000 m2 green roof on a one story
+
building in Toronto could reduce the cost of
+
cooling a building in the summer by 6% and
+
the cost of heating a building by 10% in the
+
winter23.
+
[[Category: Planning]]
[[Category: Planning]]